I very recently read an article criticising working mothers and their use of long daycare facilities. The article begins by depicting young children out in the playground at 5.30pm looking around nervously awaiting their mother’s arrival and it pulls at your heart strings whilst mentioning a young boy standing in the cold at the fence. Whilst the writer has done a very good job at creating a sad picture I feel that the intent was cruel and unfair to most working mothers. The article suggests that we are glorifying working mothers who use long daycare facilities to further their own careers and lifestyles at the expense of their children’s emotional development.
Living in Brisbane, Australia I know of many families where parents struggle financially for about six months to a year after the birth of their child, before they are forced to return to work for at least most of the working week. Simply the cost of housing, whether renting or buying, has now become so significant that the average income of a young person wishing to start a family can no longer support these costs. The choice is not always between Johnny and that next promotion, or the shiny new car in the driveway. For many it is just the financial reality of life.
So what is the alternative? Wait until we are 45 and financially well off to start having a family? My parents became grandparents for the first time at 47 and for that reason they have a fantastic relationship with their eldest grandchild. I’m not sure that would have been possible if they had to wait until they were 70 living in a retirement village somewhere.
The writer of this particular article suggests mothers should work from home slotting in work during child sleep times. I know many mothers dream of having their own business that they can run from home, working around the children. But many that have tried have soon realised that it is just not that easy. If you only have one child under two then there may be some time available in the day where you are able to use it for financial gain. But even then there are many days spent comforting a teething child, or one that is just simply under the weather and needs some extra care. These days can’t be planned ahead and slotted around important teleconference calls.
And once your child no longer has day sleeps, what then? How great is it for your marital relationship if you need to work every evening when hubby comes home and the tots in bed? And what if there is more than one child at home? What’s more young children soon learn when your attention is being taken away from them as you are urgently trying to send a quick email to avert some disaster. No matter how much you try to distract them with a book or pen and paper first before sitting down at the computer.
And managing the balance between spending time with your child, household chores and work tasks is an almost impossible feat that you may feel you never succeed in. And then you the difficulty of finding a means to earn an income from home. If it means starting your own business, this isn’t necessarily something you can do with your spare five to ten hours per week.
Now I agree that long daycare facilities aren’t for everyone. In fact our daughter, now four, hated it. So much so that we eventually decided to change her to the local Montessori school where she has blossomed and truly enjoys her time there. But I have seen many children that love the daycare environment and have become strong confident little people that have no problems in asserting themselves or creating new friendships. Not all of them are standing by the fence watching each car go past, desperately looking for Mummy or Daddy.
The most important thing that I feel needs to be said here is that there is no right or wrong answer. Every family has its own unique situation and its not the responsibility of outsiders to make judgement of the choices parents make.
I too hold empathy for the children of today, of the so-called daycare survivors or middle class warriors. But I also hold empathy for the parents of those children who feel their only option is to use long daycare facilities to house and feed their family. I’m sure for most there isn’t a day that goes by where they don’t reflect on what they have missed out on, just what did their child learn today whilst they were away?